NewTechReview: Home
| Deals | Articles | Downloads
(Free Software) | Videos | Newsletter (FREE) | Issues
| News | Reviews | Recommend
| Contest | 
RSS
Feed
 |
| Manufacturer:
AV Entertainment and Warner Bros. Disclaimer: The manufacturer provided NewTechReview with a unit of this product for review. Reviewed by the NewTechReview Staff | ||
|
||
|
This title is available at: * Website: MovieZyng.com * Amazon: Amazon.com  The James Stewart 4-Film Collection on Blu-ray is a carefully curated set that celebrates Stewart’s versatility across genres and decades, while presenting four of his finest performances in strong high-definition presentations. This set brings together The Shop Around the Corner (1940), The Mortal Storm (1940), The Naked Spur (1953), and How the West Was Won (1962), offering a sweeping portrait of Stewart’s career from romantic comedy to wartime drama, psychological western, and epic frontier adventure.First Impressions of the Collection Right out of the gate, the James Stewart 4-Film Collection Blu-ray feels like a thoughtfully assembled tribute. The set spans more than two decades of Stewart’s career, presenting four films from different eras and genres. According to the Blu-ray specifications, all four films are presented in 1080p high definition with DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono soundtracks, preserving their original audio character while benefiting from modern restoration work. The transfer quality overall is excellent, with the collection receiving high marks for both video and audio presentation, generally landing around 4.5 out of 5 in both categories. This is immediately evident when watching the films in sequence: despite their age, each feature has been handled with care and respect. The set is housed in a four-disc Blu-ray configuration, each film on its own disc, which is always a plus for bitrate and compression. It gives each movie room to breathe, and it shows. Film One: The Shop Around the Corner (1940) Story and Performances The collection opens with one of the most charming romantic comedies ever made: The Shop Around the Corner, directed by Ernst Lubitsch. Stewart plays Alfred Kralik, a clerk in a Budapest gift shop who falls in love through anonymous letters with a woman who turns out to be his co-worker Klara (Margaret Sullavan), though neither realizes the other’s identity at first. This film is a masterclass in timing, wit, and emotional nuance. Stewart’s performance is deeply human, full of quiet vulnerability and gentle humor. The chemistry between Stewart and Sullavan is exquisite, and the film’s structure, slowly revealing truths and peeling away misunderstandings, is utterly irresistible. Video Quality The black-and-white transfer here is simply lovely. The grayscale range is rich and nuanced, with excellent shadow detail and strong contrast. Close-ups reveal fine textures in costumes and facial expressions that might have been lost in earlier home video releases. Some buyer reviews on Amazon have noted that the transfer is “crisp” with “a clear sense of detail and delineation in the black-and-white image,” which mirrors my own experience watching it. Audio and Soundtrack The DTS-HD mono track is clean and clear. Dialogue is front and center, which is exactly what you want for a film built on conversation and romantic banter. There is a faint trace of age in the soundtrack at times, but it never detracts from the experience. The musical score, light and whimsical, complements the story beautifully, enhancing the emotional rhythm without ever overwhelming it. Film Two: The Mortal Storm (1940) Story and Themes Next comes the emotionally devastating The Mortal Storm, directed by Frank Borzage. Here Stewart plays Martin Breitner, a young man in pre-World War II Germany who resists the rise of Nazism. The film tells a powerful story about moral courage, love, and the collapse of society under totalitarianism. Stewart’s performance is intense and deeply felt. Opposite Margaret Sullavan once again, the two create a moving portrait of love under threat. This is a darker, more serious Stewart than in Shop Around the Corne*, demonstrating his incredible range even at this early stage of his career. Video Quality The high-definition transfer retains strong clarity and film-like grain. The snowy mountain sequences are particularly impressive, with fine detail in the landscapes and a beautiful sense of depth. Black levels are deep without crushing shadow detail, and the restoration work respects the film’s original photographic style. Audio and Soundtrack The audio track is again a mono presentation, but it is well balanced and stable. Dialogue remains clear, and the score, which leans into dramatic orchestral cues, comes through with surprising presence for a film of this age. The emotional impact of the film is heightened by its music, which underscores both the romance and the looming tragedy. Film Three: The Naked Spur (1953) Story and Performances Moving into the 1950s, The Naked Spur represents Stewart’s collaboration with director Anthony Mann, a partnership that produced some of the most psychologically complex westerns ever made. Stewart plays Howard Kemp, a bounty hunter tracking a fugitive through the rugged Colorado wilderness. This is not the gentle Stewart of his earlier films. Instead, we see a hardened, morally ambiguous man driven by greed and desperation. The film is tense, character-driven, and emotionally raw. Stewart delivers one of his most compelling performances, supported by strong work from Robert Ryan and Janet Leigh. Video Quality Shot in Technicolor and CinemaScope, the Blu-ray transfer looks stunning. The natural landscapes are vibrant, with lush greens, deep blues, and earthy browns rendered beautifully in high definition. The detail in the rock formations, forests, and sky is excellent. Grain is present but natural, giving the film an authentic cinematic texture. Audio and Soundtrack The audio presentation maintains the original mono mix, but the clarity is excellent. The sounds of the wilderness, from rushing water to wind in the trees, are crisp and immersive. The score, composed by Bronislau Kaper, is dramatic and sweeping, perfectly matching the film’s emotional intensity and rugged setting. Film Four: How the West Was Won (1962) Story and Scope The final film in the collection is the epic How the West Was Won, a sprawling frontier saga directed by multiple filmmakers including John Ford and Henry Hathaway. Stewart appears as Linus Rawlings, a trapper who marries into a pioneering family, becoming part of a generational story that spans decades. The film is narrated by Spencer Tracy and features an all-star cast. It’s an ambitious, large-scale production that captures the mythic scope of American expansion. Video Quality Presented here in a standard widescreen format rather than the curved “Smilebox” version, the Blu-ray still looks impressive. The film’s wide vistas and large-scale compositions translate well to high definition, with rich colors and solid detail. While the image occasionally shows its age, the restoration work keeps it consistently pleasing to the eye. Audio and Soundtrack The audio is again in mono, but it handles the film’s many sound elements well. Dialogue remains clear, and the film’s expansive musical score is presented with warmth and presence. The soundtrack, composed by Alfred Newman and Ken Darby, is sweeping and majestic, perfectly suited to the film’s epic tone. Packaging and Physical Presentation The physical packaging of the James Stewart 4-Film Collection Blu-ray is clean, classic, and appropriately understated. The slipcover artwork highlights Stewart in various roles, giving a visual sense of the range included in the set. Inside, the case houses four discs, each clearly labeled. The menu design on each disc is simple and easy to navigate, prioritizing functionality over flashiness. This is not an over-the-top collector’s edition with elaborate booklets or heavy extras, but it does include a modest selection of bonus materials on select discs. The focus here is clearly on the films themselves, presented in strong high-definition transfers. Overall Video and Audio Quality Across the entire set, the video quality is consistently excellent, especially considering the age of the films. The transfers are clean, stable, and respectful of the original film elements. The audio quality, while limited to mono tracks, is handled with care. Dialogue is always clear, and the scores for each film are presented with warmth and fidelity. The use of DTS-HD Master Audio ensures that even these vintage soundtracks have depth and presence, without artificial enhancement. Final Thoughts As a reviewer and a fan of classic cinema, I found the James Stewart 4-Film Collection Blu-ray to be a deeply satisfying release. It offers a well-rounded look at one of Hollywood’s greatest actors, showcasing his charm, his intensity, and his incredible versatility. From the romantic warmth of The Shop Around the Corner to the moral gravity of The Mortal Storm, the psychological tension of The Naked Spur, and the epic sweep of How the West Was Won, this set delivers four essential films in strong high-definition presentations. The video and audio quality are consistently impressive, the packaging is clean and functional, and the films themselves remain as powerful and engaging today as they were when first released. For anyone who appreciates classic cinema, or for anyone looking to explore the legacy of James Stewart, this Blu-ray collection is an easy recommendation. For more information, visit: * Website: MovieZyng.com * Amazon: Amazon.com |
| [Back to the Reviews Index] |
